Thomas begins with an anecdotal lede:
- "University presidents in Division II of the National Collegiate Athletic Association sometimes joke that they experience “ticker envy,” a yearning for the visibility that comes with a spot on the ESPN ticker."
Next, Thomas explains the general purpose of the story in the nut graf appearing in the fourth paragraph:
- "Now, members of Division II say they hope they have found their niche by offering a haven from the kind of big-time college athletics that are increasingly seen as overly commercial and exploitative."
It's at this point that Thomas uses quotes and facts to solidify the story. She first discusses specific actions taken by Division II schools such as these:
- "Under a proposal expected to be approved at the N.C.A.A. convention in January, Division II members plan to shorten the seasons in 10 sports, as well as cut back practice time in football."
- "[...]the proposal would also reduce the seasons in four sports by allowing students to report to school about a week later than they currently do. Football would not lose any games, but players would begin their preseason practice one week later. The proposal would also establish a weeklong “dead period” around Christmas in which athletes could not participate in practices or games."
- "Bob Fortosis, the athletics director at Eckerd College in Florida and a member of the Division II management council, acknowledged that the Division II proposal was rooted in a desire to cut costs, but that the motivation was also to give students more time on campus. Division II’s effort to redefine itself dates to the summer of 2005, when about 150 university presidents and chancellors met in Orlando, Fla., to discuss why several members were leaving for Division I."
From here, Thomas narrows in on how two Division II athletes were affected by the perceived stigma of playing at a Division II school; Ronnye Nelson and Maddie Dickinson:
- "Nelson’s path to Valdosta was not as simple as the division’s slogan implies. A star quarterback from Albany, Ga., Nelson said he spoke to several Division I universities but that interest waned after he tore his anterior cruciate ligament in his senior year. In the end, Nelson decided to attend Valdosta because it was close to home and 'they win a lot.'"
- "The decision was more straightforward for Maddie Dickinson, a junior goalkeeper at Seattle Pacific University, the 2008 Division II soccer champions. 'D-I has a great reputation and it would be great to play there, but it definitely wasn’t what I was about,' said Dickinson, who is from Vancouver, Wash., a three-hour drive from Seattle. 'It was about where I was comfortable, and where home was.'"
- "Norton said she saw Division II’s rebranding efforts as positive. But when asked whether perceptions had shifted, she said, 'Not yet.'"